Most impressive lineups of Servants

[Rong Nianbing]

Which is it?

From

Fate/Zero servants
Fate/SN UBW servants
Fate/Apocrypha Red servants
Fate/Apocrypha Black servants

[Overhaul]

Fate/Zero servants: Gilgamesh
Fate/SN UBW servants: Gilgamesh again, if he does not count then Arthur/Heracles
Fate/Apocrypha Red servants: Karna
Fate/Apocrypha Black servants: Vlad

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Fate/Zero servants: Gilgamesh
Fate/SN UBW servants: Gilgamesh again, if he does not count then Arthur/Heracles
Fate/Apocrypha Red servants: Karna
Fate/Apocrypha Black servants: Vlad

I meant comparing the entirety of the series to each other and which comes out on top.

Like Fate/Zero servants > Fate/SN UBW servants

[Y]

I think he means in total.

but it's

Strange Fake - True
Strange Fake - Fake
---
Apocrypha Red Faction
Stay Night
Apocrypha Black Faction ~ Zero

[Rong Nianbing]

Stay Night is actually above Zero?

Zero had Gilgamesh, Arthur, and Iskander in it's mighty lineups

[Overhaul]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

I meant comparing the entirety of the series to each other and which comes out on top.

Like Fate/Zero servants > Fate/SN UBW servants

Well then.

Red Faction ~ Zero
Stay Night
Black Faction

From the ones you mentioned.

Only top tier in black faction was Vlad.

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Stay Night is actually above Zero?

Zero had Gilgamesh, Arthur, and Iskander in it's mighty lineups

Uh.

Stay Night also has Gil, and a more powerful Arthur but

Cu > Diarmud
Heracles > Lancelot
Kojiro/F.Arm Hassan > 100 Faced Hassan
Medea > Gilles

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Well then.

Red Faction ~ Zero
Stay Night
Black Faction

From the ones you mentioned.

Only top tier in black faction was Vlad.

It's funny how the 'black' faction is the weakest

- - - Updated - - -

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Uh.

Stay Night also has Gil, and a more powerful Arthur but

Cu > Diarmud
Heracles > Lancelot
Kojiro/F.Arm Hassan > 100 Faced Hassan
Medea > Gilles

I wouldn't consider Gil a servant in Stay Night

he just happens to be alive with a physical body by then

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

It's funny how the 'black' faction is the weakest

- - - Updated - - -


I wouldn't consider Gil a servant in Stay Night

he just happens to be alive with a physical body by then

He's actively participating in the war even with a by proxy master.

It counts

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He's actively participating in the war even with a by proxy master.

It counts

What if we take him out of the equation?

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

What if we take him out of the equation?

SF True ~ SF Fake
Red Faction
Zero
FSN
Black Faction

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

SF True ~ SF Fake
Red Faction
Zero
FSN
Black Faction

That's what I expected.

Strange Fake is the one with Gil and Enkidu, right?

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

That's what I expected.

Strange Fake is the one with Gil and Enkidu, right?

Strange Fakes lineup basically consists of nothing but Top Tiers.

Gil, Enkidu, Alcides (14 different NPs, one of which can steal other NPs, every single one shown thus far is broken), One of the Four Horseman of Apocalypse who Enkidu had to flee from, NN Assassin which has all 16 different NPs of the Hassans, Hippolyta which send Alcides flying with a punch, Richard who can use Excalibur with any object he touches and has other servants as backup due to another one of his NPs, Dumas who can rewrite legends and create and combine NPs of his own which are stronger than the originals etc etc.

It's absolutely ridiculous.

[Nordlending]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

He's actively participating in the war even with a by proxy master.

It counts

In a football game you do not count the spectator running on the field a part of the line up. No matter how skilled he is.

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

In a football game you do not count the spectator running on the field a part of the line up. No matter how skilled he is.

good job on making a comparison that makes no sense whatsoever in this scenario as Gil is doing everything a proper servant summoned in the war does.

aka participating in the war.

Does the spectator actively participate as a player and has the shot to win, adhere to the rules and is bound by them all the same?

think not.

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Strange Fakes lineup basically consists of nothing but Top Tiers.

Gil, Enkidu, Alcides (14 different NPs, one of which can steal other NPs, every single one shown thus far is broken), One of the Four Horseman of Apocalypse who Enkidu had to flee from, NN Assassin which has all 16 different NPs of the Hassans, Hippolyta which send Alcides flying with a punch, Richard who can use Excalibur with any object he touches and has other servants as backup due to another one of his NPs, Dumas who can rewrite legends and create and combine NPs of his own which are stronger than the originals etc etc.

It's absolutely ridiculous.

Damn. So in that grand lineup, who's the strongest servant?

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Damn. So in that grand lineup, who's the strongest servant?

Gil is the 'strongest' Servant, period. It's stated as a hard undeniable fact multiple times, by the word of god, in the series and in extra material and Enkidu is said to be his equal. Alcides is stupidly strong and probably the very next best thing - he also hard counters Gil. The Horseman is Enkidus hard counter as well.

[Rong Nianbing]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

Gil is the 'strongest' Servant, period. It's stated as a hard undeniable fact multiple times, by the word of god, in the series and in extra material and Enkidu is said to be his equal. Alcides is stupidly strong and probably the very next best thing - he also hard counters Gil. The Horseman is Enkidus hard counter as well.

So in a fight, would Gil or Enkidu defeat the Horseman?

[Y]

This quote is hidden because you are ignoring this member. Show Quote

So in a fight, would Gil or Enkidu defeat the Horseman?

we'd need the specifics but the Horseman is likely to beat Enkidu as he's his antithesis. No idea how Gil would fare since we don't know enough at this point in time.

[Rong Nianbing]

That's some pretty crazy hype.