Tab Content
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 09:52 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I'm not dismissing the possiblility at all. You are arguing that such a role is inherently scum sided. It's not. The possibility very much exists,...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 09:09 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Never said it couldn't happen, just that your claim that it's inherently scummy is pretty flawed because of it. As for explaining it, I think the...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 08:53 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I thought I was pretty clear there. Scum-aligned double voter is a very rare role, and thus, not likely. You using the existance of a double voter...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 08:29 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    scum doublevoter/noble is realy rather rare, assuming that is the cause of the vote count being what it is.
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • VICE's Avatar
    Yesterday, 05:14 AM
    2-3 years to reach similar strength 2-3 city states to reach ouki's reputation
    14 replies | 280 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 02:12 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    If you're calling me dense, then I must be doing something right.
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 02:04 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    If you're reading desperation, then I question which thread it is you're reading. Clearly not this one.
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 02:03 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    It's only complicated insofar as the addition layers have been added upon pressure and votes coming Fab's way. Vengeful wasn't part of the original...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 02:00 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Oh, and as for "early votes tend to lead to lynches" sure, but if anything that's all the more reason not to give obvious pressure a strong reaction....
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:58 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    A role cop which we have no reason to assume exists. That's great and all, but I'd rather not just hope something exists that saves us from having to...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:56 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    The concept of fake claims for scum is something I woukd expect has been discussed for Mafia, yes. And for a player like Fab, a role that is safe to...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:53 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I don't care if you're "sure". When we talk about testing claims, we don't just assume there is a role in the game that can solve our questions for...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:51 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I mean, you yourself agreed with me on that point lol. What changed in the space of about a page?
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:46 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Additionally, your scenario is pointless. Not only does it require a specific set of circumstances wherein Fab is fsr and away the best lynch, a...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:43 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Name me one single way to confirm Fab's claim that doesn't involve assuming a role that we have no reason to believe exists in the game at this...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:42 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Fab explicitly claimed that he could still vote. That his vote counted. I even asked him to clarify, and he ignored my request. If he has since...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:38 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I think he's lying about at least one aspect of his role. Whether that makes him scum, well I don't know. I don't have enough faith to assume that...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:34 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    But it absolutely makes sense. Confirming town is almost as important as lynching scum, especially day 1. Even if you believe his claim, having it...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:32 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I don't feel like you've really thought his role through. A role that claims to survive death and keep the vote is basically begging to be lynched to...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:28 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Aside from the obvious self preservation aspects of the claim, and the fact that it can only be tested by actually lynching or killing him, it isn't...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:26 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    So, aside from how your reasoning against what I provided being pretty horrible, you also claim that myself, despite being the biggest proponant for...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:22 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Why would scum kill a role that claims to have an ability that only works upon death, with anither ability that effectively makes the role dying...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:16 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Why would the Mafia nightkill him?! There is zero (0) reason for them to do so, unless they suspect him to lying about his role entirely. Of course,...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:14 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Wrong once again. If we assume he is telling the truth, the mafia absolutely do not want us to test his claim. Because testing it will prove him as...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:11 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    This is flagrantly untrue. It is absolutely not better to lynch a player that would provide no real drawbacks for the sake of testing his claim out...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:08 AM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Just because throwaway votes can lead to a lynch, doesn't mean that all throwaway votes are something mafia will take seriously from the very start...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • VICE's Avatar
    03-17-2019, 02:37 PM
    Guardians 3 has now became a viable movie to see in the future
    7 replies | 88 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    03-17-2019, 02:01 PM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Vig = Vigilante = Town-aligned killing role. Typically, Vigs don't kill without having a clear scum target because games aren't always balanced...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    03-17-2019, 01:46 PM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    I simply don't believe you. I think you are adding elements to your claim to dissuade from the lynch, despite, from your perspective, a lynch being...
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
  • Ratchet's Avatar
    03-17-2019, 01:36 PM
    Ratchet replied to a thread Mafia 117: Mob Psycho 100 in Arena
    Now your claim is beginning to shift. I don't see me moving my vote at all at this stage.
    324 replies | 2515 view(s)
More Activity

78 Visitor Messages

  1. View Conversation
  2. View Conversation
    that's far too large. I don't have time for such a big game atm
  3. View Conversation
    How big is the game? I'm the middle of moving actually.
  4. View Conversation
    yes send me link and I'll sign up.
  5. View Conversation
    I'm not really sure what there is to update, that terminology should still be current enough.
  6. View Conversation
    ?
    Don't have a message or notification.
  7. View Conversation
    I do,I think you may have me on there actually. It's Ratchet#8597
  8. View Conversation
    When does that game start btw?
  9. View Conversation
    Nice man, where did you head to?
  10. View Conversation
    how was it?
Showing Visitor Messages 1 to 10 of 78
Page 1 of 8 123 ... LastLast
Page 1 of 8 123 ... LastLast
About Rohan

Basic Information

Statistics


Total Posts
Total Posts
340
Posts Per Day
0.45
Visitor Messages
Total Messages
78
Most Recent Message
02-02-2019 04:47 PM
General Information
Last Activity
12-27-2018 09:44 AM
Join Date
02-20-2017

3 Friends

  1. Nikamara Nikamara is offline

    Hold for applause (◡‿◡✿)

    Nikamara
  2. Ratchet
  3. VICE VICE is offline

    Serves no function

    • Send a message via Skype™ to VICE
    VICE
Showing Friends 1 to 3 of 3

12-16-2018


12-12-2018


12-01-2018


11-30-2018


11-27-2018


11-20-2018


10-28-2018


10-02-2018


09-19-2018


09-17-2018


01-25-2018


06-06-2017


05-24-2017


05-14-2017


04-25-2017


04-21-2017


03-31-2017


03-15-2017


Page 1 of 8 123 ... LastLast

12-23-2018


12-13-2018


12-07-2018

  • 08:44 PM - Acno quoted Rohan in post Hidden

12-06-2018


12-02-2018


11-27-2018


11-23-2018


11-22-2018


11-21-2018


11-20-2018



Page 1 of 8 123 ... LastLast